15 Questions to Ask a Personal Injury Marketing Agency Before You Hire Them
Burned by a marketing agency before? Use these 15 questions to separate a true PI specialist from a generalist. Learn what good and red-flag answers look like.
Rafael Hernandez
CEO and Co-Founder of Great Marketing AI


I hope you find this useful. If you want our team to run your law firm's performance marketing, book a strategy call.
Author: Rafael Hernandez | CEO and Co-Founder of Great Marketing AI
Key Takeaways
- Ask how many active PI law firm clients the agency has right now. A real specialist has a focused, verifiable roster, not a mixed portfolio of industries.
- Confirm the agency can attribute signed cases back to specific campaigns, not just leads or clicks, before you sign anything.
- Ask directly whether they hold a geographic exclusivity policy. A good agency will not run the same playbook for a competing firm in your market.
- Get clear on what your monthly report includes. If they lead with impressions and reach instead of signed cases, that is a red flag.
- Understand the fee structure up front: what you pay in management fees, who owns the ad accounts, and what happens to your data if you leave.
- Ask specifically about Spanish-language campaign capabilities if you serve bilingual clients. This is a hard operational skill, not a last-minute add-on.
Most personal injury law firm owners who have been burned by a marketing agency made the same mistake before signing: they asked the wrong questions.
The right questions reveal whether an agency genuinely specializes in personal injury marketing or just claims to. They expose whether the agency can track signed cases back to specific campaigns, how they handle attorney advertising compliance in your state, and whether they will stay invested in your results six months in, not just the first 90 days.
Below are 15 questions to bring to any PI marketing agency interview. Each one includes what a good answer sounds like and what a red flag sounds like. The goal is to give you a verification rubric, not a promotional script. A real specialist should be able to answer all 15 with specifics, not generalities.
If you want a broader framework before you start meeting agencies, read how to choose a personal injury marketing agency first. Then bring this checklist to every conversation.
These questions apply to any agency you evaluate, including Great Marketing AI. We built this list because a firm owner who asks harder questions makes a smarter hire, and we are prepared to answer every one of them on a call.
Questions 1 through 5: Specialization and Vertical Experience
1. How many personal injury law firms are you actively working with right now?
Why it matters: Volume tells you whether the agency's PI expertise is real or theoretical.
Good answer: "We currently work with eight active PI clients across different markets and can connect you with two or three of them as references." The agency should be able to name firms or describe their cases without hesitation.
Red flag: "We have worked with a few law firms over the years. We also work heavily in healthcare and professional services." Generalist experience does not translate to PI case economics, conversion funnels, or intake dynamics.
2. What percentage of your revenue comes from personal injury law firms?
Why it matters: An agency that derives most of its revenue from legal clients will know the compliance landscape, conversion funnel, and intake dynamics of PI marketing. One that treats legal as a small vertical will not.
Good answer: "Personal injury law firms represent about 60 percent of our client base. It is our core vertical."
Red flag: "We work across many industries, but we are very adaptable." Adaptable is not the same as specialized. PI marketing has specific constraints, including state bar compliance, strict case attribution requirements, and bilingual intake considerations, that take real experience to navigate.
3. Do you work with competing PI firms in my city or practice area?
Why it matters: If an agency runs campaigns for two MVA firms targeting the same metro area, your ad spend competes with theirs on the same auction. Your budget helps drive up the cost per lead for their other client, and theirs does the same to yours.
Good answer: "We hold a market exclusivity policy for direct competitors in the same DMA. We will not take on another MVA client in your market while you are a client." Ask to see this language in the contract.
Red flag: "We handle that through internal processes." There are no meaningful separations in a shared ad account strategy. If two clients are bidding on the same keywords in the same city, they are competing against each other.
4. Can you walk me through a real campaign you ran for a PI firm in a market like mine?
Why it matters: Case studies are your proof of concept. Real campaign data tells you far more than a polished pitch deck.
Good answer: The agency walks you through a real campaign, explains the targeting decisions, the ad creative approach, the conversion funnel, and shares specific metrics, including cost per lead or cost per case, for that client's market.
Red flag: "We cannot share client information due to confidentiality." A legitimate agency will share anonymized results, high-level metrics, or offer to connect you with a current client who can speak on the record. A blanket confidentiality claim is often a shield for a lack of results worth sharing.
5. How do you stay current with attorney advertising rules in my state?
Why it matters: Every state bar has its own advertising rules. Some restrict the use of case results or testimonials, others regulate solicitation and required disclaimers, and all of them carry compliance consequences that fall on the attorney, not the agency. The American Bar Association's Model Rules of Professional Conduct provide a baseline, but your state bar's rules are what control.
Good answer: "We audit every ad against your state bar's attorney advertising rules before it goes live. We have a compliance checklist specific to your state and include required disclaimers automatically."
Red flag: "We follow FTC guidelines and industry best practices." FTC guidelines govern general advertising, not attorney advertising. The answer must name your state bar specifically.
Questions 6 through 10: Tracking, Reporting, and Accountability
6. How do you attribute signed cases back to specific campaigns?
Why it matters: Clicks and leads are inputs. Signed cases are the only output that matters for a PI law firm. Without case attribution, you cannot know which campaigns are generating revenue and which are draining budget.
Good answer: "We integrate with your intake CRM, use dynamic number insertion to track calls to the campaign source, and review which signed cases came through our leads at 30, 60, and 90 days. We report cost per signed case, not just cost per lead."
Red flag: "We track leads and conversions in Google Analytics." Google Analytics tracks form fills and call clicks. It does not track whether someone signed a retainer agreement three days later after a second callback.
7. What does your monthly report include, and what does it leave out?
Why it matters: The metrics an agency chooses to report on tell you exactly what they want you to focus on. Rafael Hernandez, CEO of Great Marketing AI, frames it this way: "The agencies that hide behind impressions and reach metrics are the ones who know their campaigns are not converting. A real performance agency leads with the number that matters to the client: cases signed."
Good answer: A real report covers ad spend, leads generated, cost per lead by campaign, signed cases attributed (with a defined lag window), and month-over-month trends. It tells you what is working and what is being adjusted, and it commits to a number.
Red flag: A report that leads with impressions, reach, and engagement rate, with no connection to intake or signed cases.
8. What happens when a campaign underperforms for 60 days in a row?
Why it matters: Any agency can run strong campaigns in a good month. The real test is what they do when results slide. This question reveals whether the agency has a documented optimization process or simply waits and hopes.
Good answer: "At 30 days of underperformance, we run a full audit of creative, targeting, and landing page. At 60 days, we present a revised strategy with specific changes. You will never go 90 days without a concrete plan and a decision point."
Red flag: "Marketing takes time. You need to give it at least six months before judging the results." Accountability should not be deferred indefinitely. A six-month window with no review checkpoints is a flag.
9. Do you use the Meta Conversions API and Google enhanced conversions?
Why it matters: iOS privacy changes and browser-level tracking restrictions have significantly reduced the accuracy of standard pixel tracking. The Meta Conversions API sends conversion data server-side, bypassing browser restrictions and giving the ad algorithm cleaner signals to optimize toward.
Good answer: "Yes, CAPI is implemented across all Meta campaigns. We pass lead and appointment data server-side so the algorithm understands what a real conversion looks like, not just a page view."
Red flag: "We use the standard Meta pixel." A standard pixel alone is no longer sufficient for accurate attribution on Meta, particularly for PI firms where conversions happen over the phone, not through a form submit.
10. What platforms do you run for PI firms, and what is your reasoning for each one?
Why it matters: Platform selection should follow your client type and funnel. Google Search captures high-intent prospects already looking for a PI attorney. Meta reaches a broader audience that needs to be educated before converting. The right mix depends on your market, budget, and target client profile. For context on how to measure your law firm marketing ROI across each channel, the attribution model matters as much as the channel itself.
Good answer: "We run Google Search to defend your core terms and capture high-intent demand, and Meta for broader reach, including bilingual creative for MVA clients. The channel mix shifts based on your cost-per-case target and your intake team's capacity."
Red flag: "We focus on social media because it has the best ROI for law firms." Platform-agnostic claims without market-specific reasoning are a flag. The right answer depends on your specific market.
Questions 11 through 13: Intake Integration and Lead Quality
11. Do you run Spanish-language campaigns, and how does your intake process handle bilingual leads?
Why it matters: Spanish-speaking MVA clients represent a significant underserved segment in most major markets. Running Spanish-language ads without a bilingual intake process wastes the budget: the lead comes in and cannot be handled in the caller's preferred language. A true specialist in Spanish-speaking MVA lead generation has both the creative capability and the intake handoff process built out.
Good answer: "We produce Spanish-language ad creative in-house and work with your intake team to make sure Spanish-speaking callers are routed to a bilingual coordinator. We do not run Spanish-language campaigns if you do not have bilingual intake coverage. It wastes your money."
Red flag: "We can translate the ads into Spanish." Translation is not a strategy. Ask whether the agency has run Spanish-language PI campaigns before and can show you results.
12. What lead response time do you expect from my intake team, and do you monitor it?
Why it matters: A study published in the Harvard Business Review found that companies who respond to inbound leads within an hour are far more likely to qualify that lead than those who wait even a few hours. In PI, where a prospect may call two or three firms before choosing one, response time directly affects your cost per signed case.
Good answer: "We recommend a maximum five-minute response time for inbound PI leads. We track answer rates from your intake team and report on them. If the answer rate drops below 80 percent, we flag it because it inflates your overall cost per case."
Red flag: "That is an operations issue on your side. We just deliver the leads." Lead quality and intake performance are connected. An agency that ignores intake capacity is not truly accountable for your case economics.
13. How do you filter for lead quality before a call reaches my intake team?
Why it matters: Unfiltered traffic sends your intake team calls from people outside your target case type, jurisdiction, or insurance status. Quality controls protect both your team's time and your ad budget.
Good answer: "We use negative keyword lists, audience exclusions, and call qualification scripts to filter irrelevant traffic before it reaches your team. We also review call recordings periodically to identify patterns in unqualified callers and refine targeting."
Red flag: "You will get a high volume of leads and your intake team can sort through them." Volume without quality is a cost center, not a revenue driver. Volume-first pitches usually mean the agency is optimizing for a metric they control, not the one you care about.
Questions 14 and 15: Contract Terms and Fee Structure
14. What are your contract terms, and what are my options if results do not meet agreed targets?
Why it matters: A long lock-in contract with no performance exit clause shifts all the risk onto you. A confident agency should be willing to tie at least some part of the relationship to defined performance thresholds.
Good answer: "We have a six-month minimum to give the algorithm time to optimize. However, if we miss the agreed case target by a defined percentage for two consecutive months, you have the right to exit with 30 days notice. Here is the specific language." Get it in writing.
Red flag: "We require a 12-month minimum commitment because results take time." A twelve-month minimum with no performance exit option is a flag. Ask specifically what recourse you have if results never materialize.
15. How is your fee structured, and who owns the ad accounts if I leave?
Why it matters: Fee transparency is one of the top buying criteria for law firms evaluating agencies, according to the Legal Marketing Association. You should know exactly what portion of your budget is the management fee versus ad spend, and you should retain ownership of your ad accounts and the data inside them.
Good answer: "Our management fee is separate from your ad spend. You own your ad accounts. If you leave, you take your account history, your pixel data, your audiences, and your creative assets with you. We do not hold your data hostage."
Red flag: "Our fee is bundled and your ad spend runs through our master account." Bundled fees with agency-owned ad accounts mean you lose all historical data and algorithm optimization if you ever switch agencies. Starting over from scratch has a real cost.
You Now Have the Rubric
These 15 questions are a verification tool. Bring them to every agency conversation, including ours. A real specialist will answer all 15 with specifics, reference actual clients, and hand you contract language that backs up what they say.
The firms that regret their agency hire usually did not ask hard questions before signing. The firms that build a long-term, results-driven agency relationship usually did.
If you are ready to put us through this checklist, schedule a call with Rafael. He answers these questions himself, walks through real campaign data, and gives you client references you can actually call.
Turn Ad Spend Into Signed Cases
We blend AI-driven testing with proven performance strategy to attract qualified traffic and turn it into revenue—fast, trackable, and scalable.
- PI Lead Generation — exclusive, AI-qualified leads across MVA, slip & fall, med mal, and more.
- Facebook & Instagram Ads — reach customers where they scroll.
- Google Ads — capture people actively searching for you.
- Website Design — turn visitors into buyers with high-converting sites.
- AI Automations — save hours and never miss a follow-up.
- Email Marketing — nurture leads and close sales on autopilot.
- SEO — get found by customers searching for what you sell.
FAQs

About the author
Rafael Hernandez
CEO and Co-Founder of Great Marketing AI
Rafael Hernandez is the Founder of Great Marketing AI and a former Microsoft Engineer. He specializes in performance marketing for personal injury law firms, managing over $10M in ad spend to help attorneys generate signed cases across every PI case type. His strategies focus on exclusive lead generation, AI-powered qualification, and eliminating wasted budget.
About Great Marketing AI
Great Marketing AI: Performance marketing for personal injury law firms
We help personal injury law firms scale with exclusive, AI-qualified leads across every PI case type: MVA, slip & fall, medical malpractice, and wrongful death. Native English and Spanish campaigns, enterprise-grade Meta + Google ad management, and AI lead qualification before every intake.
100% Exclusive Leads
Never shared between firms. Territory-protected.
Native Spanish & English Campaigns
Built by native speakers, not Google Translate.
AI Lead Qualification
Pre-qualified before they ever reach your intake team.


